What Is Going On With the Handball Law?!

  • Publisert 2 måneder siden

    HITC Sevens

    Runtime: 12:04

    Following the decision to award a penalty to Newcastle United against Tottenham Hotspur in the Premier League at the weekend, everyone from managers like Roy Hodgson and Steve Bruce to Sky Sports pundits like Gary Neville and Jamie Carragher has criticised the amendments to the handball law in football.
    So in this short documentary, HITC Sevens takes a look at why the changes to the handball law were made, who introduced them, and how likely they are to be reversed.

subito zx
subito zx

The FA has been intentionally trying to kill the game, same as the nfl, nba, mlb, etc

Måned siden
Sean Delap
Sean Delap

Its becoming an absolute farce and is ruining the game of football.

Måned siden
Strappa Plank
Strappa Plank

great vid, thanks mate

Måned siden
Ramiro Rybczuk
Ramiro Rybczuk

- Here, we need to have some sympathy for the referees * stadium starts piping crowd boos *

2 måneder siden
Michae V
Michae V

why can't sky sports or the BBC explain the referee's position on the rules like you have? Broadcasters are terrible!

2 måneder siden
Jack Mellor
Jack Mellor

I remember PGS being knocked out of the Champions League by Manchester United by a similar interpretation in 2018-19 season. Remember Rushfords last minute penalty?

2 måneder siden
Siyabonga Dube
Siyabonga Dube

It’s no longer hand ball it’s arm ball

2 måneder siden
Cristian Gutierrez
Cristian Gutierrez

I do not owe anybody anything now with the help of, *p a i d t o b e h o m e .c o m*

2 måneder siden
Debayan Bhunia
Debayan Bhunia

I think strikers should aim for defense's hands rather than the goal now

2 måneder siden
John McCosh
John McCosh

The Eric dire was a handball as his hand was in an unnatural position no matter if the ball was headed at his hand it was still a handball

2 måneder siden
Andrew James
Andrew James

Top 7 worst rules in football

2 måneder siden
Vincent Smith
Vincent Smith

Bro do a "best individual seasons in premier league history"

2 måneder siden
Vicwilliam Vinsent
Vicwilliam Vinsent

who cares abt souness

2 måneder siden
none anon
none anon

Yeah a lot of these handball pens have been farcical this season. Look if the offending player isn't even aware of the ball (which can be observed from VAR) then how could he intentionally use his arms unfairly to his advantage? This rule needs to be amended surely.

2 måneder siden
Genesis TV
Genesis TV

Jus‘ don use ya fokin hand mate

2 måneder siden
funsponge
funsponge

Ads too long

2 måneder siden
1 Airpod
1 Airpod

Can u make a video on the Mexican league since it’s one of my favorite leagues and it has a weird format on who wins the league

2 måneder siden
Gabriel Moreira
Gabriel Moreira

There was one game in the brazilian league that they disallowed a goal because the ball hit the strikers hand but the ball only hit the strikers hand because it hit first the defenders arm and then went to hit the striker and they just disallowed the goal

2 måneder siden
mfm
mfm

seven defenders to score hattrick

2 måneder siden
mfm
mfm

seven defenders to score hattrick

2 måneder siden
mfm
mfm

seven defenders to score hattrick

2 måneder siden
mfm
mfm

sevens defenders to score hatrick

2 måneder siden
Basilio Damacio
Basilio Damacio

This stupid law has already killed one cl final. It needs to change or revert back to the old one

2 måneder siden
James Thomas
James Thomas

Would love to see "7 of the closet title races in Europes top 5 leagues"

2 måneder siden
Eli Griffen
Eli Griffen

Everyone who sees this, have an amazing day and I hope that you are well.

2 måneder siden
Jonjo Sharp
Jonjo Sharp

Do every teams worst players best performance

2 måneder siden
guy man
guy man

Every sunderland players most ridiculous hand ball moment ever. HD

2 måneder siden
clive henry
clive henry

It's the usual top 4 who will moan the most

2 måneder siden
Why Why
Why Why

Might as well tie your hands behind your back before playing

2 måneder siden
FireIcarus
FireIcarus

You know, I wasn't expecting a soccer equivalent of the NFL's formerly awful catch rules, but here we are.

2 måneder siden
Jordan nadroJ
Jordan nadroJ

In all fairness, this law makes 442 way more viable.

2 måneder siden
Jordan nadroJ
Jordan nadroJ

Gary be watching this. Top video as always 👍

2 måneder siden
belgium is my city
belgium is my city

Best XI outside the big five leagues

2 måneder siden
jeff shipley
jeff shipley

Thanks for a video. Really hope they change this

2 måneder siden
Orlando Thompson
Orlando Thompson

Last year, VAR didn’t give any penalties until November, but PGMOL changed that halfway through the season, so could do the same with this?

2 måneder siden
LakeSnake
LakeSnake

VIDEO IDEA: The premier league table if it was in Alphebetical order.

2 måneder siden
Bodie Thomas
Bodie Thomas

7 best players to never play in the champions league

2 måneder siden
Joseph Fernando
Joseph Fernando

Pretty soon instead of football, the game will be called foot-ball-hand-pen

2 måneder siden
Football talks
Football talks

1.2k like!!!!!!! YAY!!!!!!!

2 måneder siden
Mark White
Mark White

last season 91 penalties after the season was finished 3 weeks in 20 penalties already !!!! 20 pens in 3 game weeks is mad

2 måneder siden
Shahid Willie
Shahid Willie

Thanks for the news

2 måneder siden
Y T
Y T

Very pertinent point made with the refs

2 måneder siden
Lukinjo
Lukinjo

7 Best players that cost less than 20m pounds

2 måneder siden
Mujeeb Ahmed
Mujeeb Ahmed

Its a ridiculous rule and one I can't understand..

2 måneder siden
INGRAO
INGRAO

premier league fans just finding out, Serie A fans after having a year of this.......

2 måneder siden
Eli Murphy-Trotzky
Eli Murphy-Trotzky

The "natural position" part of the rule needs to go. It should need to be deliberate.

2 måneder siden
Zak Ihsan
Zak Ihsan

sad that the referees have to give a yellow card to a player taking off his shirt revealing a message or else they wouldn't be able to feed their family wtf is happening to the game

2 måneder siden
SpamQGamers
SpamQGamers

Its also a political, imagine what would happen in terms of advertisement if the ref didn't penalise a pro hong kong message, and so all must be penalised and treating all issues equally. The kneel down and the 1 min silence after a death or tragedy are technical before the game and so the FA, FIFA, etc... can remain neutral at least by the letter of the law

2 måneder siden
mar
mar

Rating every PL midfielder of all time who went to move to and/or came from Real Madrid from worst to best (beckham, bale, james, etc)

2 måneder siden
Turnips
Turnips

You might as well slice of every defenders arms if the rules are as they are right now

2 måneder siden
Rodrigo Lyra
Rodrigo Lyra

Soon it will be required to have no arms to be a defender

2 måneder siden
ONCEUPONATIME!
ONCEUPONATIME!

I honestly don't think it's as big of an issue as people are making it out to be

2 måneder siden
ellibod1
ellibod1

I’m a Newcastle fan and I think our penalty was bullshit

2 måneder siden
tdyerwestfield - OFTW OG
tdyerwestfield - OFTW OG

How do referees score any points from their advisors at all? Michael Oliver must be the only referee in the country that has ever scored any points.

2 måneder siden
tdyerwestfield - OFTW OG
tdyerwestfield - OFTW OG

Why did they change the handball law? 'Deliberate or not deliberate' was far clearer than 'natural or unnatural position' because there's no such thing as an unnatural position unless someone is deliberately trying to handle the ball.

2 måneder siden
Jungwoo Kim
Jungwoo Kim

"As an Ivorian used to say, 'It's a disgrace, it's a fcking disgrace!'"

2 måneder siden
Morten Christensen
Morten Christensen

Something interesting about this specific incident is the possible argument that VAR did not call what happened as a whole in the situation, and if they had called it fairly they would have given a freekick to Dier for Wilson's push in the back forcing Dier to flail his arms for balance. It normally is not enough for a freekick, but seeing how it directly forced the penalty it should have been an overruling call. It may be a bit of a stretch, but it's an interesting point of view in regards to further improving the use of VAR.

2 måneder siden
Elmer Wilber
Elmer Wilber

@Morten Christensen Ah ok I knew I saw someone's head offside

2 måneder siden
Morten Christensen
Morten Christensen

@Elmer Wilber I believe they checked it and ruled no. I remember seeing them going through that check, picture-wise. Fernandez was offside but Carroll wasn't. At least it would've been another one of those silly millimeter offsides that we don't want VAR to call in the first place.

2 måneder siden
Elmer Wilber
Elmer Wilber

Wasn't Andy Carroll offside leading up to the handball as well??

2 måneder siden
Giancarlo Torres
Giancarlo Torres

You should make a video on the VAR in germany and compare it to the Premier

2 måneder siden
Willtr
Willtr

What about the decision in Chelsea’s game right at the end? Where because of the new laws kai havertz handballed it’s in West Brom’s box and it didn’t count as a handball.

2 måneder siden
Folarin Alabi
Folarin Alabi

Day 8: 7 greatest football mavericks/entertainers. Here is the list Jay Jay Okocha Ronaldinho Len Shackleton Garrinha Frank Worthington Alan Hudson Paul Gascoigne

2 måneder siden
charlie moore
charlie moore

what’s the point of asking if you just make the list yourself?

2 måneder siden
Juan José Oñate
Juan José Oñate

This rule is idiotic. If I was a coach I'd practice provoking handballs with my players. Can you imagine? Dribbling always intending to either mantain possesion or force the ball to hit the defender's hands or arms. I'd get five penalties per game.

2 måneder siden
Isaac Fung 馮皓朗
Isaac Fung 馮皓朗

Day 27: 2012-2013 and 2019-2020 Bayern Munich Combined XI

2 måneder siden
Isaac Fung 馮皓朗
Isaac Fung 馮皓朗

@José Rondón Same as me

2 måneder siden
José Rondón
José Rondón

Neuer Lahm Boateng Alaba Davies Schweinsteiger Thiago Robben Müller Ribèry Lewandowski

2 måneder siden
Ricardo Martins
Ricardo Martins

The rules of football should be much more objective. Unless the player does like Maradona, it is very difficult to be sure whether or not there was an intention to play the ball. What doesn't make any sense, is that it is not FIFA, the organization that rules football, the ones who sets the rules of the game.

2 måneder siden
shane mcinerney
shane mcinerney

I like the law it makes the game more exciting, and you don't know what will happen until the final whistle

2 måneder siden
José Rondón
José Rondón

“It’s ruining the game” when the first interesting thing happened in an absolutely dreadful match between Spurs and Newcastle was certainly a weird take.

2 måneder siden
smn han
smn han

Your recent form is better then mane's. Also a quick video idea, top 7 managers who played within the last 7 years (or something along that line) thanks!

2 måneder siden
Bryan Jones
Bryan Jones

Had to get that Hull reference in.

2 måneder siden
PlaythenSay
PlaythenSay

"..the premier league adopt one set of rules and uefa stick to with the original set.... could be problematic" Like they have every year up to this season?

2 måneder siden
Eisen Adler
Eisen Adler

I'm done with association soccer. Imma go watch USA football from now on.

2 måneder siden
SPQSpartacus
SPQSpartacus

The Newcastle penalty vs Spurs was absolute insanity. In future, all players must have their hands surgically removed or stiched to the sides. Especially in the penalty area, a conscious move by the defender should be required and rulings go against penalty unless obvious.

2 måneder siden
Random
Random

These rules are bull-the-$#|+ .... They're ruining football

2 måneder siden
Hong Ee Ng
Hong Ee Ng

Correct decision the player clearly moves his hand from bottom to top when he jumps and the ball hits his hand, so clearly penalty, if in the other hand, if he jumps up and dun move his hand, then it is not penalty, rule books just says if players move and hit the ball, is hand ball, so no doubt it is penalty, referee cannot knows the player's intention and judge penalty or not, he can only judge based on wat he sees

2 måneder siden
Lewis does a bit of shiny hunting
Lewis does a bit of shiny hunting

This is why no one wants to be a referee, but that’s why I do want to.

2 måneder siden
Joel Sati
Joel Sati

7 underachieving golden generations

2 måneder siden
Lewis does a bit of shiny hunting
Lewis does a bit of shiny hunting

Why did I have 2 Wolves attackers and their keeper in my fantasy team this week? That result was so West Ham.

2 måneder siden
K_Teck
K_Teck

BBC's MOTD have already pretty much covered this subject...

2 måneder siden
José Rondón
José Rondón

As daft as the rule is, haven’t the last couple of game weeks been incredibly entertaining because of it? The new offside was way worse as it was disallowing perfectly good goals. I don’t see why any neutral would be annoyed that we’re getting more goals.

2 måneder siden
D M
D M

Teams working hard and dominating whole game to loose by some shitty rules. It's not entertaining. It's not okay to find joy in someone's getting screwed over. As a neutral fan also it's depressing mate. Hope you understand it lad

2 måneder siden
Tom Spencer
Tom Spencer

Alfie, these rules were in place in Europe last year. What are European leagues and clubs doing about these rules? Did they not complain to IFAB in the close season??

2 måneder siden
Milorad Babic
Milorad Babic

I couldn't disagree with this rule any more that I do now. In my opinion, any rule that has the potential to alter the outcome of the game based on a completely involuntary action of a player, like being struck in the arm, is a bad one. One thing though, this has been happening quite some time before, even in major events such as the World Cup. For example, being from Serbia, I remember the penalty awarded to Germany in the 2010 WC against our national team under similar circumstances

2 måneder siden
Chad Sexinton
Chad Sexinton

Fantastic vid Alfie, I feel informed. It’s gonna be a long painful season though, I assume every team will be negatively affected by this rule during the season, just judging by the amount of penalties already given in 3 match weeks.

2 måneder siden
Ongoing Discovery
Ongoing Discovery

Considering that roughly 90% of goals this season will be penalties, how about the best penalty taker in every position?

2 måneder siden
Val Zod
Val Zod

@Vitor Carvalho i think he was being hyperbolic. But yes you are probably right. Still a very high rate

2 måneder siden
Val Zod
Val Zod

@Ongoing Discovery lol

2 måneder siden
Ongoing Discovery
Ongoing Discovery

Cabra Cabeluda Hyperbole: (noun) exaggerated statements or claims not meant to be taken literally. This might be a new concept for you so I googled the dictionary definition for you

2 måneder siden
Cabra Cabeluda
Cabra Cabeluda

More like %17.5

2 måneder siden
Alex
Alex

Fire vid

2 måneder siden
RABBITBOY/\/\
RABBITBOY/\/\

I'm not giving sympathies to the refs because in the spurs game there were about 4 handballs committed by Newcastle in the penalty box, all way more obvious and in a more unnatural position than diers arm. The next change the IAFB need to make is firing themselves.

2 måneder siden
Raskolnikov
Raskolnikov

"Reactionary" doesn't mean when you're reacting to something. Cheers

2 måneder siden
mcsqueeb187
mcsqueeb187

adjective: reactionary opposing political or social progress or reform I mean that is what the video is about...

2 måneder siden
José Rondón
José Rondón

YES! Hearing this word misused all the time drives me absolutely nuts.

2 måneder siden
midknight
midknight

Only United gets corners (from a ball that went out off their own player) after stoppage time, and penalties awarded after the full time whistle

2 måneder siden
DJ Silversun
DJ Silversun

Theres nothing wrong with penalties being awarded after the full time whistle as long as they are correct penalty decisions

2 måneder siden
Bernhard Sonn
Bernhard Sonn

I thought England was a rough League with less pens than in other Leagues

2 måneder siden
Looná Vanza
Looná Vanza

All time Premier League 11 vs All time La Liga 11 And same could be done for other Leagues SeriesA, League1 and Bundisliga As a Series and ranking which league comes 1st 2nd 3rd 4th 5th in historic 11s

2 måneder siden
Cameron Mellor
Cameron Mellor

S J ye but I still feel like it would be very complicated

2 måneder siden
Siyabonga Dube
Siyabonga Dube

This needs 200 likes

2 måneder siden
Looná Vanza
Looná Vanza

@Cameron Mellor cr7 have played more for blancos then with red devils so he represents la liga

2 måneder siden
Cameron Mellor
Cameron Mellor

S J ye but what about players like cr7

2 måneder siden
Looná Vanza
Looná Vanza

@tom spreadbury yes brother that's what I mean

2 måneder siden
Miklos Hajma
Miklos Hajma

Idk if you played football on the pitch, you know that you basically can't do anything against a ball arriving from a few meters within the 60-90 km/h speed range. Human reflexes can't do that, just the visual reaction time is at 240ms in average, I guess most professional players are slightly better, but that's not enough to notice the movement AND do something against it.

2 måneder siden
Abha Agrawal
Abha Agrawal

It was ruining Serie a last season too...

2 måneder siden
D M
D M

Are they still using it this season?

2 måneder siden
jason casey
jason casey

Why not just cut the arms of all the football players that way you can never get a hand ball in the game

2 måneder siden
Galuh Pratama
Galuh Pratama

Irish guy would kill for ireland vs france wc 2010 playoff rematch

2 måneder siden
k3D4rsi554maq
k3D4rsi554maq

I'm more annoyed with the Irish team for failing to score a second goal, than anything Thierry Henry did.

Måned siden
Connor, the android sent by CyberLife
Connor, the android sent by CyberLife

8:55 why is that a rule? It's so damn stupid... Is it just down to getting sponsors on TV?

2 måneder siden
Carwyn Gregory
Carwyn Gregory

It was originally introduced to stop time wasting

2 måneder siden
Asentseto
Asentseto

Ludogorets video soon please:)

2 måneder siden
jason casey
jason casey

We need to go back to the old way to the rules and stop all the bull shit it’s getting very boring to fans

2 måneder siden
Aubameyang's Memes
Aubameyang's Memes

VAR HAS GONE TOO FAR

2 måneder siden
Röss Åke
Röss Åke

...and everyone is seemingly blaming VAR for this. The handball law is pretty harsh at this point - If I could, as a teenager flick it into a player's gonads "for the bantz" during warm up, I'm sure as the day is long that professionals can aim for arms these days.

2 måneder siden
José Rondón
José Rondón

The rule wouldn’t exist if there was no VAR though. VAR needs binary decisions and common sense goes out of the window.

2 måneder siden
Manav Arun Aravind
Manav Arun Aravind

No VAR too like goal line technology is amazing because it is bonafied a goal or not I'd much rather have referees refereeing the game tha VAR and this handball rule is like when a few ppl who just started football saying if it touches your hand it's a foul

2 måneder siden
Morten Thor Rasmussen
Morten Thor Rasmussen

I think these are the best handball rules we've ever had. They are clear and everyone gets penalties awarded for the same thing. I´ve hated that penalties were given due to interpretations by the referee. It is by no means perfect and we need to address the fact that players can aim the ball at the opponents arm or similar. But i vastly prefer this over former rules.

2 måneder siden
Omar Adnan
Omar Adnan

The real problem are the people who manage and supervise the refrees

2 måneder siden
Fadhili Deche
Fadhili Deche

I think I've commented this before on one of your previous videos, but isn't it surprising that there hasn't been any movement towards trying to do away with the mandate that players have to be booked when they celebrate by taking their shirts off? It sounds like another one of those rules that's universally disliked even though not many people would go so far as to say that it's ruining the game.

2 måneder siden
Youki Yoshida
Youki Yoshida

Im not even going to debate the handball rule because dumb rules are still rules, but just look at the "foul" that led to the freekick before the "handball". Joelinton sees that his pass is going to be intercepted and so he just dives at Hojbjerg and the ref calls it a foul. This along with the fact that Wilson, who is in an offside position, pushes Dier in the back as he goes up for the header. All in all, the standard of refereeing is not good enough.

2 måneder siden
Eric Ji
Eric Ji

Change the rule quickly,or players would aim at defenders' arms,then it would be a penalty. Or the defenders have to cut off their arms if the ridiculous handball rule remains.

2 måneder siden
Theriac33
Theriac33

This is seen in field hockey when the team in attack are trying to aim a defender's foot to get a penalty in front of goal.

Måned siden

Neste

Jurgen Klopp's 7 Best Signings of All Time

11:02

The Furry Disease

3:34

The Furry Disease

Flashgitz

Ganger 1,2 mill

WHO IS THE BEST COUPLE ON YOUTUBE?

35:01

WHO IS THE BEST COUPLE ON YOUTUBE?

Miniminter

Ganger 1,7 mill

Can't Lose the Love Handles? Just Do THIS!!

8:08

96 Hours Inside Afghanistan in 2020

33:56

96 Hours Inside Afghanistan in 2020

Yes Theory

Ganger 2,1 mill

HOW I became...Erling Haaland

25:42

HOW I became...Erling Haaland

DW Kick off!

Ganger 1 mill

The Zipf Mystery

21:05

The Zipf Mystery

Vsauce

Ganger 18 mill

How Apple Just Changed the Entire Industry

26:28

The Crazy Story of Inter Miami

19:52

The Crazy Story of Inter Miami

HITC Sevens

Ganger 195 k

7 Most Infamous Curses in World Football

13:23

Have Manchester United Run Out of Money?

15:52

Best of: Jose Mourinho "The Special One"

27:12

Best of: Jose Mourinho "The Special One"

beIN SPORTS USA

Ganger 1,4 mill

The Furry Disease

3:34

The Furry Disease

Flashgitz

Ganger 1,2 mill

WHO IS THE BEST COUPLE ON YOUTUBE?

35:01

WHO IS THE BEST COUPLE ON YOUTUBE?

Miniminter

Ganger 1,7 mill

Can't Lose the Love Handles? Just Do THIS!!

8:08

96 Hours Inside Afghanistan in 2020

33:56

96 Hours Inside Afghanistan in 2020

Yes Theory

Ganger 2,1 mill

When DJI says: 'BLOW OUR MINDS'

3:16

When DJI says: 'BLOW OUR MINDS'

Peter McKinnon

Ganger 443 k

MIKE TYSON VS ROY JONES JR FULL FIGHT EXHIBITION (HD)

32:59

Dumpster Diving To Build The Best Weapon

17:08

Arsenal vs Wolves | Watch Along Live

2:31:05